We share what we learn.

A group's central functions face questions that have no settled answer, such as which emission factor a row in the general ledger should have. Nobody has all the answers yet, and everyone benefits when more people share what they know. Here we go into them in depth: what the standards and research say, where there is no right answer and how we have approached it. We publish them openly, so that others can build on the work and we can learn together.

In depth

  1. Why don't we book emissions like money?

    In the 13th century the bankers of Florence solved a problem that carbon accounting still has: two parties keeping separate accounts, with neither one's entry pointing to the other's. This article covers what double-entry bookkeeping did, how much of what companies calculate for their purchases is estimated, how accounting researchers and others try to carry the principles over to emissions, how the draft standard MASSIV+ tries to solve what has been identified as difficult, and the obstacles to booking emissions the way we book money.

  2. Which emission factor belongs on each row of the general ledger?

    Scope 3 for purchases is usually calculated with spend-based factors, and for every row in the general ledger someone has to choose which one. The GHG Protocol's four methods and the data they require, what an input-output factor does and does not say, how to separate large from small and where the choice has no right answer. Then our method: every row broken down into materials, a language model trained on the experts' judgements and factors that are documented and locked per year, what we have seen in general ledgers and in municipalities' supplier ledgers, and what is still open.